When it works, it works very well, and in the right setup, it’s a genuinely useful upgrade.
I want to start by saying; I have been using the S1 Plus for a few months now and I really like it, I do recommend it. Especially for print farms or anyone running very large-format printers. I’m using it with the Creality Ender 5 Max specifically to support long-duration prints and to fully utilize filament spools. One of its biggest advantages is eliminating those last unusable loops of filament, which is a small but meaningful efficiency gain over time.
That said, my experience hasn’t been without issues, and they’re worth noting if you’re considering this for a similar setup.
The main challenge I’ve encountered is reliability in filament feeding during transitions. On a few prints, the filament was properly engaged by the gearbox, but when switching from one side, it would occasionally catch or bind instead of feeding smoothly. When this happens, the system doesn’t recover gracefully, it simply stops pushing filament, which can lead to a failed print.
This problem is compounded by compatibility limitations with the stock Creality filament runout sensor. It isn’t designed to accept a PTFE fitting on the input side, which makes integration awkward. I attempted to add an adapter, but it introduced additional catching point and didn’t fully resolve the issue. I’ve since ordered a BIQU filament sensor, which should be better suited for this kind of setup, though I haven’t tested it yet.
Running without a filament sensor is risky in this case. If a feeding issue occurs, the printer won’t pause, it will continue printing without material, effectively ruining the print unless you’re willing to salvage it by reprinting missing sections and assembling them manually.
It’s also important to mention that some of the issues in this setup comes from the printer itself rather than the S1 Plus. The stock extruder on the Ender 5 Max isn’t designed with a PTFE tube fitting, meaning you typically have to remove the tube entirely for filament changes. When using the S1 Plus, it can push filament into the extruder, but it may also push the PTFE tube out under pressure, once this happens the filament keep from the S1 as there is no back pressure for the S1 to sense, so it keeps feeding.
There are a few ways to address this:
Adding a custom PTFE adapter to the top of the stock extruder (I designed and printed one myself) Quickest and easiest fix.
You can Download it here. > Creality Cloud -Ender 5 Max InfinityFlow adapter From Any Idiot https://www.crealitycloud.com/model-detail/693365fc1d09900e7de0fdac
Upgrading to a K1-style extruder
Switching to a DXC extruder. (Requires modification to fit.)
Overall, the S1 Plus is a strong tool with clear benefits for large-scale or continuous printing, but it’s not entirely plug-and-play—especially with stock Creality hardware. If you’re comfortable making a few hardware tweaks and dialing in your setup, it can be a worthwhile addition. Otherwise, be prepared for some trial and error to get consistent performance.
Happy Printing and thank you Infinity Flow.